Transcript of meeting #1 for Territorial Leadership Committee in the 13th Assembly.

The winning word was chairman.

BIP Revisions
Nominations For Premier
Election Of Premier

Page 33

Jane Groenewegen

Jane Groenewegen Hay River

Thank you, Mr. Chairmen. I'm not maybe completely up to speed on what the latest revisions ere to the business incentive policy, but my understanding of it is that it is a percentage of margin where northern businesses could bid a higher price and still win a contract on a public tendering process. I believe it's 10 per cent end five per cent additional for local. I support this policy. I think that we do have to recognize the fact that the cost of doing business in the North is higher, and the gains to our economy by keeping business in the North are not entirely quantifiable, but we need to support northern business.

I would say in terms of revisions, I think we need to look at closing loopholes in the policy whereby southern firms can take out a mailbox, get an address, a fax number and a phone number in the North and be recognized as a northern business. Storefront operations are not acceptable. We want, not only in the construction sector but in other sectors also, to give that competitive edge to our northern companies end I believe that the benefits from that are quite substantial. Thank you.

BIP Revisions
Nominations For Premier
Election Of Premier

Page 33

The Chair Samuel Gargan

Thank you. We've reached the half- way point. Out of an expected 88 questions, we've only had about 44 questions asked so far. So we're a long ways, but there has been a request to take a short break by the candidates so we'll take a 15-minute break.

---SHORT BREAK

BIP Revisions
Nominations For Premier
Election Of Premier

Page 33

The Chair Samuel Gargan

The House will come back to order. I guess the general consensus is that we continue until a Premier is selected. So the next speaker is Mr. Ningark, followed by Mr. Ng.

Awarding Of Contracts To Northerners
Nominations For Premier
Election Of Premier

Page 33

John Ningark Natilikmiot

Thank you, Mr. Chairmen. Good afternoon. This is with regard to what the last speaker was asking about. It is in relation to the business incentive policy. In every community across the NWT, such as Lutsel K'e, Lac La Martre, Clyde River, Gjoa Haven, Pally Bay, Repulse Bay, young people are looking for jobs. In small communities, there are cases where an individual, a young person can be brought down to the lowest common denominator. In many cases we have suicides, we have social problems, we have many other social problems across the Territories. The human being was designed to be active, to work and to be busy. In my age group, when we used to go out camping we used to be busy all the time. There were hardly any social problems because we kept working, moving and being active.

We know in today's standard, when there is a government contract or project in the community, in some cases we have contractors coming in from larger centres like Edmonton, Alberta, Ontario, Yellowknife, in some cases, to a smaller community. In most cases, Mr. Chairman, the local contractor, the owner of a local contract, a person who lives in the community, was born in the community, was raised in the community put in bids for contracts. In some cases, the contract is not awarded to the person who has always lived in the community. Thereby the community is not able to take the benefit from the government projects.

I don't know if the business incentive policy is going to be reviewed; we haven't really determined that because we haven't really picked out the Cabinet and the Premier. I would like to get the response from both candidates in this area if in fact the business incentive policy is not reviewed, can I get a commitment from both that perhaps they are able to commit that at least 80 per cent of the projects or contracts are awarded to a local company and will remain in a community. As we all know, we talked about social problems; in fact, we spent millions of dollars trying to combat the local social problems . Bringing in specialists, having programs and services is a beginning but it is not the total answer, Mr. Chairman. Ensuring that people in the community, young people, middle aged, having the benefit of the government projects, actually working in the government projects in their respective communities. A local contractor, owner, a person who was born or has lived in a community all their life should be given that benefit. I would like to get an answer from both candidates, are they going to commit, in the event the business incentive policy is not reviewed to tell this leadership that you will at least commit to 80 per cent of that money staying in the community. I know it's a tall order, but we have to try and resolve the social problems that we have within the jurisdiction.

Awarding Of Contracts To Northerners
Nominations For Premier
Election Of Premier

Page 33

The Chair Samuel Gargan

Mr. Morin.

Awarding Of Contracts To Northerners
Nominations For Premier
Election Of Premier

Page 33

Don Morin Tu Nedhe

Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Over the past four years, our government has made advances in this area of local people working. I fully agree that local people should work on the construction jobs in the communities, local people should

benefit from those jobs. I don't think I can commit to the Member that 80 per cent of the work will stay within local people's hands, or 80 per cent of the dollars. We know already that approximately 50 per cent of the dollars are spent on material which normally has to be bought from our regional centres. We have made moves in the past with the building and learning strategy to make sure that our people at the local level get trained. I've made moves, as well, through our contractual procedures, our tender documents, to ensure that we have the hammer so that if people working at the community level don't hire people at the local level they can be removed from the business incentive policy -- their company -- or they can be removed from the contract. So we do have that hammer.

The key is to get the training programs into our communities and get the people trained to handle those jobs themselves. In a lot of our communities, the local people are now doing the majority of the work themselves, but we always have to work to ensure that local people continue to benefit. We have to ensure that even our local companies hire locally. In the past, some of our companies that are northern and local brought in people from the South, so the business incentive policy didn't address that issue. Hopefully, a new business incentive policy will address that issue. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.

Awarding Of Contracts To Northerners
Nominations For Premier
Election Of Premier

Page 34

The Chair Samuel Gargan

Thank you. Mrs. Groenewegen.

Awarding Of Contracts To Northerners
Nominations For Premier
Election Of Premier

Page 34

Jane Groenewegen

Jane Groenewegen Hay River

Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I would like to tell the honourable Member that I empathize completely with what he saying with respect to our social problems and the lack of work for our young people. As a government, I think we have to take initiatives that restore that pride and dignity to people so that they can see the fruit of their own labours and they can take pride and purpose in what they are doing. So as a government, I don't know what I can commit to in terms of percentages, but I can tell you where I stand personally. I think as a government we need to find that balance between being fiscally and socially responsible. We are under budgetary restraints and so there could be arguments made for getting the job done as cheaply as possible, but you would have to have blinders on to look at that alone and not see that if you are carrying the majority of a small community on social assistance that it is in fact costing the government more than it would to give a local company an advantage of whatever percentage in order to put their people to work. So I can tell the Member that I personally am very keenly aware of this and I think that it will just take a very balanced approach to address that issue. Thank you.

Awarding Of Contracts To Northerners
Nominations For Premier
Election Of Premier

Page 34

The Chair Samuel Gargan

Thank you. Again, just to remind the Members again about their long preambles. Mr. Ningark, your second question.

Delegation Of Portfolios
Nominations For Premier
Election Of Premier

Page 34

John Ningark Natilikmiot

Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Mr. Chairman, I know some honourable Members have asked questions with regard to the portfolios to be in the system. During the 12th Assembly, some of the honourable Members, most of the ordinary Members were of the opinion that the Premier at the time was overworked. We appreciate the fact that she's a workaholic. Everyone knows that she works very hard. But the Premier or the leader of the pack has to learn to delegate responsibilities. I would like to ask both candidates how they see the role of Premier. Are you going to be taking over some of the responsibilities of some of the portfolios, or are you willing to delegate all the responsibilities to the other Ministers so that you then could be free and running the government, overseeing the fine operation that's being done within your domain? Thank you.

Delegation Of Portfolios
Nominations For Premier
Election Of Premier

Page 34

The Chair Samuel Gargan

Mrs. Groenewegen.

Delegation Of Portfolios
Nominations For Premier
Election Of Premier

Page 34

Jane Groenewegen

Jane Groenewegen Hay River

(Microphone turned off)...former Premier, I'm not so sure that she was a workaholic by choice. I wasn't close enough to the government to really be able to assess that but, for whatever reasons, she saw tasks that needed to be done and portfolios that needed to be managed that she felt she had to do herself.

As I said before, we are hopeful that this Cabinet will be full of workers and doers. I think that the concept of a Premier being without portfolio is an interesting concept and one that I would not toss out of hand. I see the Premier as the captain, the motivator and the delegator. If the workload could be distributed evenly enough amongst capable Cabinet Ministers, I wouldn't totally dismiss the idea that the Premier could be without portfolio. Thank you.

Delegation Of Portfolios
Nominations For Premier
Election Of Premier

Page 34

The Chair Samuel Gargan

Thank you. Mr. Morin.

Delegation Of Portfolios
Nominations For Premier
Election Of Premier

Page 34

Don Morin Tu Nedhe

Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I look at the names that have been up already that I know of of Members around this Assembly and they all look like very capable people to me. I, too, would have to see what comes out of the wash at the final end to see how you would hand out the portfolios and who you would delegate which departments to. I, too, would look seriously at whether or not the Premier has to take any portfolios. I would have to sit down with the Members of the Legislative Assembly, with the people, and discuss that issue with them to see what they feel once we see what comes out of the final vote. Thank you.

Delegation Of Portfolios
Nominations For Premier
Election Of Premier

Page 34

The Chair Samuel Gargan

Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Ningark. Mr. Ng.

Initiatives For Budget Management
Nominations For Premier
Election Of Premier

Page 34

Kelvin Ng Kitikmeot

Thank you, Mr. Chairman. My question is, of course, to both candidates. I would like to ask them what creative new ways of doing business -- of course, in our business it's operating government -- what would they undertake, what new changes would they implement to address the serious fiscal situation that we have facing us. Thank you.

Initiatives For Budget Management
Nominations For Premier
Election Of Premier

Page 34

The Chair Samuel Gargan

Thank you. Mr. Morin.

Initiatives For Budget Management
Nominations For Premier
Election Of Premier

Page 34

Don Morin Tu Nedhe

Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Like I said in my speech, we have to look at the most effective way of getting the dollar from this level to the community level. We have to get the best bang for our dollar. We have to look at the duplication in government, we have to get rid of the duplication in government and we have to cut the bureaucracy, the layers of the bureaucracy. It takes far too much to get things from the community level to this level, and we have to do that as soon as possible. But in order to do that, we all have to sit down together and come up with that plan. All 24 of us have to have input into that plan. Once all 24 of us set the direction that the government is going to go, then it's up to the Premier and the Cabinet to follow that direction and try to make it work. Thank you.

Initiatives For Budget Management
Nominations For Premier
Election Of Premier

Page 35

The Chair Samuel Gargan

Thank you. Mrs. Groenewegen.

Initiatives For Budget Management
Nominations For Premier
Election Of Premier

Page 35

Jane Groenewegen

Jane Groenewegen Hay River

Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and thanks for that question. What creative ways could we think of to address our fiscal situation? I think we need to re- examine everything. I think that sometimes in government we get used to doing business in a certain way and we don't think about different ways that we could do things. With no disrespect, I think sometimes we just get in a rut and say well, that's the way we've always done it. I think we really need to break out that. I agree with Mr. Morin that there is a lot of duplication, and I referred to that quite extensively in my remarks that I made before.

With respect to cutting the bureaucracy, I think that there are also ways that we can do that without causing hardship to people. I'm thinking of early retirement, volunteer retirement packages and I'm also thinking of saving money by attrition when people leave positions that don't have to be refilled; ways of cutting costs and cutting the bureaucracy without injuring and hurting the people who are in the civil service.

I guess just in response to that, I don't think that anything is really sacred, I think we just have to look at everything.

I'll give you one brief example of the kind of thing I'm talking about. I'm really concerned about northerners who are living in southern institutions. I'm sure that the Members would be surprised at the kind of dollars the territorial government pays to the federal government. It used to be more so in health also, but in the areas of social service that we say we're used to writing that cheque every month so we don't stop and think about it and say is there any way that we could keep this money and keep these people, keep our people here and look after them here. Like I said, I referred to that in my speech but it's just one small example where we sort of have to challenge the status quo and say how can we do this differently and how can we do it better, and ask that infamous question; why do we do it that way? Thank you.

Initiatives For Budget Management
Nominations For Premier
Election Of Premier

Page 35

The Chair Samuel Gargan

Thank you. Mr. Ng.

Community Transfers
Nominations For Premier
Election Of Premier

Page 35

Kelvin Ng Kitikmeot

Mr. Chairman, my second question is with regard to community empowerment. We know that there's an escalating demand out there from communities, under the community transfer initiative, to take on new assets and to take on more programs and authorities at the local level from the territorial government, although the process seems to be bogging down and the demand is high. I would like to ask both candidates what their positions are on community transfers of GNWT programs and if they support them, how can they enhance or accelerate that transfer to the community level and, if they don't support them, why not.

CHAIRMAN (Mr. Gargan): Thank you. Mrs. Groenewegen.

Community Transfers
Nominations For Premier
Election Of Premier

Page 35

Jane Groenewegen

Jane Groenewegen Hay River

Thank you, Mr. Chairman. With respect to community transfer agreements and initiatives, I think that wherever it makes sense and there is a political will on the part of the people to take something over, I think it can be valuable and it can be successful. There are some logistical realities to the working out of these things. In some really small communities, you may not just have the processes and expertise, administration and things in place to administer programs. The reality is, in a lot of small communities, a lot of people are...I'm thinking of, for example, the area of social assistance. That is one that Health and Social Services has tried to transfer to the communities. If you get into a small community situation and a lot of the people in a small community are related to each other, they just become sort of logistical problems in delivering the service. If that's the case, then we almost are in danger of crossing that line where we're going to duplicate and it's going to cost more money. So I think that we should look at some measures like is there will on

the part of the community, is there agreement amongst the various groups that this is what they want to do, and does it make sense from a monetary perspective. If it does, then I would be in full support of it.

The community of Hay River, at this time, is looking at taking over from...it was actually a contract previously, but with respect to our hospital. The GNWT is taking that back over and is looking at transferring that to the community. With what we have set up in terms of infrastructure, I think that could be quite a possible transfer.

So we just need to look at each community individually, what they want to do, are the transfer feasible and judge each one on its own merit. Under those conditions, I would support community transfers. Thank you.

Community Transfers
Nominations For Premier
Election Of Premier

Page 35

The Chair Samuel Gargan

Thank you. Mr. Morin.

Community Transfers
Nominations For Premier
Election Of Premier

Page 35

Don Morin Tu Nedhe

Thank you, Mr. Chairman. I do support a community taking over the decision-making and the running of government programs in their communities. I believe it is a cost-saving measure, and I believe it can solve many different problems. Possibly the community transfer initiative is maybe too complicated for some of the communities to proceed to take over program delivery in their communities. But I do know that we have transferred some responsibilities to some of the communities, and I believe the process should be simplified. For example, you look at the Housing Corporation and DPW, if you manage the maintenance at the community level and combine the two, you'll save money. You could also use that same maintenance crew to manage projects in the community and that way you will employ local people and they can run their own projects, whether it be construction or maintenance. By doing that, I think as a government we can save money. Thank you.