This was a business decision that was made for all the reasons, all the factors, political factors, technical factors, legal factors, all the other constraints and variables that are there, and we made a business decision on this project. That’s what it was. We chose to go down a path that did not involve trying to invoke clauses in contracts and getting involved in the middle of completing a project that is 90 percent complete, protracted legal battles.

I want to acknowledge the Finance Minister’s position of calling it a business decision. That sounds a lot nicer than the words I may have used. I’d like to make a motion. I move that this committee defer consideration on the activity highways under the Department of Transportation, capital investment expenditures, Supplementary Estimates (Infrastructure Expenditures), No. 1, 2011-2013, on page 13, at this time.

Thank you, Mr. Hawkins. The motion is being distributed. The Members all have the motion. The motion is in order. The motion is not debateable.

---Defeated

We are on page 13, Transportation, capital investment expenditures. Mr. Yakeleya.

Madam Chair, I want to ask the Minister on the bridges that are being worked on in the Sahtu region, because of the increase of the traffic over the winter season, and it’s going to get worse in a good way, that we need to look at the bridges. I want to ask the Minister on the bridges in the Tulita area and outside Norman Wells that those bridges need to be taken care of. Will that happen this winter?

Thank you, Mr. Yakeleya. Mr. Neudorf.

I would ask if the department, again, would look at establishing themselves in the Sahtu for reasons that the deputy minister talked about. We need to now start tracking the amount of vehicles that are going to be using that road, especially from Tulita and Norman Wells, and also

coming up from the southern portion of the road. We need to start looking at our infrastructure. For example, the bridges at Four Mile Creek and Prohibition Bridge. Those two bridges there, and possibly other future bridges, but these are the ones that for me in the Sahtu that are key, even at 12 Mile Point. When the department starts looking at moving its presence, a temporary office in the Sahtu to look at some of this increased traffic and fix these bridges, and that I expect that this department will do it.

I have heard over a number of seasons, reasons why we aren’t able yet to put bridges in the Sahtu, and I no longer am going to accept the deputy minister’s opinion that there are a number of factors. It can get done. Today is June. I’m telling you right now, you can have this done by this winter season. For myself, there are many projects in the North that Transportation is looking after, and I think the one in our region needs not to be delayed anymore. I can give other examples, but I don’t think it’s the time right now. It’s Friday and I want to get this budget approved and passed and get to work. I’m sure that the Transportation department is well aware of the bridges that I’m talking about. I’ll ask the deputy minister to work on it. I’m going to come back in October. If I have to be in the House again to do another Member’s statement, I will. Thank you.

The Department of Transportation has some well dedicated staff. Maybe they might be overworked, because we got a lot of money from Transportation and the federal government to put projects right across the Northwest Territories. We certainly, in the Sahtu,

could also help with some of these projects here, with the transportation, the design, the work. We can also even take some of this project management. They did a wonderful job in Colville Lake. The department and the community put together a good team and they put the airport there. It can get done. I think the department needs to give a little more credit to the communities in the regions for taking over some of these projects, and it can get done probably under budget or just right on budget. It can get done.

I ask the Minister and the deputy minister of the Department of Transportation, we could do this work and get it done in the Sahtu, and put together these projects on time and on budget. For example, we have some work on the airports and the winter roads, and it’s going to get busy this winter. If the Explorers Group tells us, you know, when they’re going to spend maybe over $200 million. I’m not too sure if that’s a correct number, but that’s what they say they’re going to do. We need to get ready for that and we can have a temporary office set up in the Sahtu with some of their instructors, that could look after the bridging, work on the airport, other than getting approval out of Fort Simpson or out of Inuvik. We just don’t have that mechanism. We have to make that phone call to Fort Simpson or to Inuvik to get work done in the Sahtu. Those 1950s, ‘60s days are over. It’s 2012. Why can’t we get the approval done in the Sahtu? I don’t understand. Is it really that hard to let that type of authority go in the department?

The big boys are playing in the Sahtu for oil and gas, so we need to play along with them to get things done. I ask again, the Department of Transportation, you have some very good people working in your department. We have some real good people working in the Sahtu. Those roads are going to need to be upgraded and I see that they’re putting signs on the winter road. I’ve driven the winter road from here to Wrigley, Deline, to Fort Good Hope and the Wells. I’ve been on those winter roads. There’s a lot of improvement. The signs are no longer tagged onto a tree. They’re actually posted now on the road. That’s showing me that there is some attention and there’s improvement.

We have a really good ice paving program. It’s good that you’re doing some good work there. What we see in the amount of activity going on there on our winter roads, and the oil companies are coming up and our people are seeing this. The other areas like Good Hope to Norman Wells, the road is pretty rough. This is our transportation for the three months. This summer we got the Mackenzie Valley River. That’s our transportation right now. I’m talking now just on the winter roads, and I’d like to see this department step up to the plate and put an office, a position, even temporarily, in the Sahtu, so we can have some autonomy and some authority,

instead of making that phone call to Simpson or to Inuvik to say can we do this, can we do that. We’ve got to have that. That’s what I’m asking in a forceful way to the department on these projects here, because I’m seeing these bridges certainly need to be fixed and it’s not getting done for the reasons that the Minister or the deputy minister has said to us in the House here. That’s all I have to say on page 13.

I well remember the discussions when we had this very similar debate. The Member might have been involved, as well, when we were talking about moving Health out of Inuvik to give the economy to the people in the Sahtu. I think that process is underway. We have commitments on decentralization. We are looking at how we do this, and going forward I think I know we will get there, but I’ll ask Minister Ramsay if he wants to speak to the issue so we can give the Member some comfort from the Minister himself. Thank you.

Thank you, Minister Miltenberger. Minister Ramsay.

Thank you, Madam Chair. We have had a great deal of success working with industry in the Sahtu when it comes to winter roads. We’re looking forward to continuing that partnership with industry as the resource is developed in the Sahtu. We are also looking for more opportunities to partner with industry. There is potentially a lot more opportunity when it comes to winter roads in the development of winter roads in the Sahtu. Potentially, the opportunity I think will also exist for all-weather roads once the resource is developed and it’s more proven up. I do believe there is a tremendous opportunity to work with industry and the federal government to see some permanent all-weather roads built in the Sahtu.

I know we just had a meeting with Husky recently. They are intent on building 35 kilometres of all-weather road across the river from Norman Wells. There are opportunities there. There is the Sahtu Explorers Group. At the earliest opportunity, we will be meeting with that group to discuss opportunities and possibilities for the Department of Transportation and the Government of the Northwest Territories to work with industry to advance our mutual goal, and that is to improve the transportation infrastructure in the Sahtu. We certainly look forward to that.

In regard to the Member’s comments about staffing and resourcing offices in the Sahtu, again, I think as development continues and activity increases in the Sahtu, those types of staffing resources will certainly have to be given a great deal of consideration by the government and by the department. I want to thank him for raising those concerns. Mahsi.

Thank you, Minister Ramsay. Members, before we go on, I would like to recognize a visitor in the gallery, Mr. Sonny Greenland, who is here visiting from Inuvik. Welcome to the House.

Members, we are on page 13, Transportation, capital investment expenditures, highways, not previously authorized, $62.342 million. Mr. Hawkins, do you have anything new to contribute to this discussion?

Absolutely, Madam Chair. I just wanted to use the opportunity to thank my colleagues, all who voted against me; you too. I want to use the opportunity to thank my colleagues, especially the Members on this side of the House, for allowing me the chance to articulate some of my concerns. I’m disappointed by not getting the answers I would like, but I also recognize Minister Miltenberger had said twice at the end of each last chance he had to comment, which is ultimately a political and a business decision, so I just wanted to put that on the record. Clearly, I will be voting against this supp. I think I have said my piece. Thank you.

Thank you, Mr. Hawkins. Page 13, Transportation, capital investment expenditures, highways, not previously authorized, $62.342 million.

Thank you, committee. Page 14, Transportation continued, capital investment expenditures, road licensing and safety, not previously authorized, $881,000.

Transportation, total department, not previously authorized, $72.103 million.

Page 15, Industry, Tourism and Investment, capital investment expenditures, tourism and parks, not previously authorized, $64,000.

Thank you. Total department, not previously authorized, $64,000.