Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Again I will summarize the reason that we have a motion which talks about another constituency is because of the fact that in the Model C that we have approved to recommend to the Minister, the community of Sanikiluaq which is in my present constituency, is paired with the community of Whale Cove.
For those that are not familiar, the two communities are very far from each other. They are in two different administrative districts or regions, have no family ties and have very different dialects. Although it is all in the new culture, the cultural ways are different.
I do not know for sure, the reason for the pairing of these two communities in the report, but as I said previously, in my general comments, I believe that in going with the 17 seats, the commission had limited flexibility in how it divided up the seats. Therefore, this political judgment is left up to us, the politicians.
What I would like to do is just illustrate briefly the problems that are created by having a constituency that is very large and that does not have good transportation links.
I presently represent the communities of Cape Dorset, Kimmirut and Sanikiluaq. I have to tell you that it is probably the most difficult constituency in all of the Northwest Territories to get to. It takes me several weeks just to be able to get in a couple days in each constituency. The cost between lqaluit and Sanikiluaq for example for an air charter is over $7,000, that is just one community and for one meeting. With my constituency budget I believe being around $30,000 you can see how many constituency meetings I have in that community. Let alone the other two communities.
You can, still speaking on the costs, being a bit more frugal, you can do different things to try to keep that cost down. For example, you go in on split charters and you can go with other organizations, such as I did with the Baffin Region Inuit Association this past winter and which I did at one point with the MACA at another point. In the two years that I have represented the constituency, I have been in that community six times, and that is an average of every four months. That does not seem like a lot, but that is more than double than the two previous MLAs having visited those communities in the four years. I am not kidding.
Just recently, I sent my constituency assistant Johnny Manning to go to Sanikiluaq on my behalf. I could not go due to an invitation by the Minister of DIAND to meet her at the time. I sent my constituency assistant to go down for some meetings with the different groups in the community and to hold a radio phone - in show on this subject and on others Because there is one flight a week from Iqaluit to Sanikiluaq. and it is not a scheduled flight, it is what they call a charter. Although it is scheduled, it is still a charter because there is never enough passengers to fill the plane and to pay for the cost.
Mr. Manning left on a Thursday on my behalf, was suppose to leave on a Thursday, but was delayed by one day and ended up going down on a delayed flight. It took him almost three weeks to get back home, even though he was down there for one phone-in show and several constituency meetings with different groups.
Now imagine for MLAs who live in Yellowknife or who live in Iqaluit or have been in Baker Lake, you go out to have a constituency meeting and it takes you three weeks to get home. It sounds like a fairy tale story but that is exactly what happens right now. It is unacceptable. It is almost unmanageable.
Now the way the Model C proposes is to pair Sanikiluaq and Whale Cove together. That is equally unacceptable, because there is no transportation links. It would take an MLA who will be based out of Iqaluit at the time because that is where the Legislative Assembly will be, to hold one meeting in each of those two communities, one constituency meeting. If Sanikiluaq and Whale Cove were paired together that person will have to travel, and I am not kidding, 9,600 kilometres to have a meeting in each of the two communities. That is totally unacceptable.
I propose that Sanikiluaq because of the difference in culture, dialect, et cetera and the remoteness, that Sanikiluaq requires. desires and deserves its own seat. I point out to you MLAs the letter that I tabled yesterday from Mayor Kattuk explaining why. He talks about the population growth is high, that they are geographically remote, that they have no ties to Whale Cove, et cetera. I will leave the rest of the reading for you Now why, if I want a seat for the community to have its own MLA, why would I propose that Arviat go with Whale Cove? Well, it is because of the report or the way the report is laid out and the fact that we do need to make a recommendation. In recommending that Sanikiluaq have its own seat, we have to make a decision on what to recommend for the representation of Whale Cove. If you look on the map at the community of Whale Cove and its location, its transportation links, its family ties, its culture, and its dialect language, the whole nine yards, you will note that the two closest communities are Rankin Inlet and Arviat.
Now because of the way the new constituencies are divided up, there is no question in my mind that Rankin Inlet deserves and must have its own seat. There is no questions about that. That is what I would recommend. But that still leaves Whale Cove out in the cold.
So the next best thing for the community is to be represented by an MLA who represents Arviat. As you can see in Model C, Model C recommends that Arviat have its own seat where as right now it is divided up between, paired up with Baker Lake. So, if you catch my drift, that is the reason for the motion.
I do, if required have other information and other things I could say to the motion. I have spoken with many Members and I am confident that MLAs understand the needs of Sanikiluaq and I hope would vote for the motion. If this goes through, this is not the end of the work as yet. There are opportunities in the future for other boundaries commissions if this relationship does not work out between the two communities. It is open for debate. We can look at it again. With that, I would ask Members to support the motion which pairs Whale Cove with Arviat but the overall intent and effect is for Sanikiluaq to have its own seat and to be recognized for its uniqueness and its needs. Thank you very much.