This is page numbers 732 - 780 of the Hansard for the 13th Assembly, 3rd Session. The original version can be accessed on the Legislative Assembly's website or by contacting the Legislative Assembly Library. The word of the day was ---agreed.

Topics

Revert To Item 5: Recognition Of Visitors In The Gallery
Revert To Item 5: Recognition Of Visitors In The Gallery

Page 748

The Speaker Samuel Gargan

Welcome to the Assembly. Item 5, recognition of visitors in the gallery. Mr. Henry.

Revert To Item 5: Recognition Of Visitors In The Gallery
Revert To Item 5: Recognition Of Visitors In The Gallery

Page 748

Seamus Henry Yellowknife South

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Earlier today, Mr. Art Sorensen was recognized by my colleague. His wife, Lynda Sorensen, is in the gallery today and I would like to recognize her as a Member of my constituency and also Mrs. Sorensen's mother, Christine Klotz. I would like to welcome her to Yellowknife and to the House.

---Applause

Revert To Item 5: Recognition Of Visitors In The Gallery
Revert To Item 5: Recognition Of Visitors In The Gallery

Page 748

The Speaker Samuel Gargan

Thank you. Item 5, recognition of visitors in the gallery. Item 7, written questions. Item 8, returns to written questions. Mr. Clerk.

Return To Written Question 5-13(3): Education Issues In The Baffin Region
Item 8: Returns To Written Questions

Page 749

Clerk Of The House Mr. David Hamilton

Mr. Speaker, Return to Written Question 5-13(3), asked by Mr. Barnabas.

The following replies are in response to the six written questions asked by Mr. Barnabas on May 16, 1996.

1. There are five communities in the Baffin which will have more than one school next year. Will the Department of Education provide the Baffin Divisional Board with funds to allow every community school to have a school counsellor?

In the past, school community counsellor positions were allocated to communities which had a trainee in the training program. This resulted in an unequal distribution of counsellors. The new funding formula is more equitable because funding for counselling is now based on enrolment. The changes in the contribution funding formula are intended to support the autonomy of boards and school districts, and to prepare for division of the Northwest Territories in 1999 by distributing resources equitably across the NWT.

Since the Baffin Divisional Board of Education had a higher ratio of counsellors to students than other boards and, as a result of the new funding formula, the number of counsellor positions within the Baffin board decreased while positions in some other jurisdictions increased. Funding for counsellors will increase with increases in enrolment.

In addition, the department has recently considered the results of the review of the school community counsellor program. The review recommends closer ties between school community counsellors and community wellness programs. It further recommends that the Department of Education, Culture and Employment work with Health and Social Services to integrate counsellor training. The department will be pursuing these recommendations with Health and Social Services.

2. Will school community counsellor positions be built into the funding provided to divisional boards of education for the community grade extensions?

The department is looking at the issue of grade extensions to see what is needed to improve support, which includes counselling, for high school programming.

Forced Growth

3. Is there a supplementary reserve built into the 1996-97 budget which will be available to provide formula funding increases to respond to the growth in the student enrolments?

During the past meetings with the board directors and superintendents, the idea of establishing a reserve fund to respond to extraordinary student enrolment increases was discussed. The boards did not want the department to hold back funds. Establishing a reserve fund meant adjusting the pupil/teacher ratio. As a result, no reserve was established for the 1996-97 school year.

4. If the department now only considers supplementary funding after increases of more than eight per cent, does that mean we must wait two years before the Baffin can receive supplementary funding for the number of students we have?

Funding is based on prior year enrolment. Therefore, student enrolment increases would be reflected in the following year's contribution. For 1995-96, the department requested supplementary funding to address the above-average enrolment increases on behalf of the boards. The department has indicated to the boards that the possibility of supplementary funding for 1996-97 is very limited.

McGill University Tuition Fees For TEP Students

5. Is it true that the Department of Education is refusing to pay for these fees for 1995-96?

The Department of Education, Culture and Employment did not pay McGill University tuition fees for 1995-96. In the summer of 1994, the Department of Education, Culture and Employment advised Nunavut Arctic College that it would not be responsible for the additional tuition fees for McGill courses, effective in the 1995-96 academic year. The department funds the college for all delivery costs of the teacher education program. The department advised the college to meet with McGill to resolve the issue of fees and to identify alternate institutions to deliver the required courses if necessary.

The college reviewed the agreement with McGill and the fee arrangements remained in place. Following notification from the college of this arrangement, the department advised the college that all costs associated with the agreement would be the responsibility of Nunavut Arctic College.

University transfer agreements between northern public colleges and universities provide accredited training for northerners. Generally, however, such arrangements do not include a cost to the northern colleges. For example, the current arrangement for teacher training provided at Aurora College is accredited through the University of Saskatchewan, at no cost to the college.

6. Will the Department of Education, Culture and Employment be paying the McGill tuition fees for TEP students at Nunavut Arctic College for 1996-97?

Nunavut Arctic College staff have had opportunity to review and resolve the matter. Their decision to review the agreement with McGill University has direct cost implications for which the college is being held accountable. The department will not pay the McGill tuition fees for TEP students at Nunavut Arctic College for the 1996-97 academic year.

Return To Written Question 5-13(3): Education Issues In The Baffin Region
Item 8: Returns To Written Questions

Page 749

The Speaker Samuel Gargan

Thank you. Item 9, replies to Opening Address. Mr. Miltenberger

Item 9: Replies To Opening Address
Item 9: Replies To Opening Address

Page 749

The Speaker Samuel Gargan

Mr. Miltenberger's Reply

Item 9: Replies To Opening Address
Item 9: Replies To Opening Address

Page 750

Michael Miltenberger

Michael Miltenberger Thebacha

Mr. Speaker, on October 16, 1995, 24 of us were given a mandate by the people of our constituencies. We, the Members of the 13th Assembly, knew we had many serious issues to deal with: the way we do business as an Assembly; the deficit, which literally grew before our eyes; division and constitutional development in the West; huge social problems; and, of course, the need for economic development. It is now May 29th and we have completed two important steps: we've significantly changed the way we do business as the Legislative Assembly; and we are just about to complete our first budget, making hard decisions that have never had to be made before in the history of this territory.

Mr. Speaker, many people said our new way of doing business would not last; that we were in a honeymoon phase and that we would quickly revert to the adversarial politics of the previous Assembly as soon as it was time to make hard decisions. Mr. Speaker, this Assembly has, in my opinion, successfully passed its first major test. With 24 MLAs, there is a wide range of opinions and perspectives. Some thought our budget didn't cut enough, some thought it cut too much. What we achieved, in my opinion, is a healthy compromise. We all agree that we have to eliminate the deficit, but discussion centres on how and when.

We have used our new approach in all our business in the House. The pace and work has been unrelenting and my opinion will continue to be unabated. I see no change in pace as we race the clock on the way to 1999 and division. It is by continuing to work together as we have up until now that we will be able to cope with the formidable agenda before us. Mr. Speaker, I'd also like to note that any success that we achieve is a result, in no small measure, of the hard work and the dedicated staff throughout all the departments, boards and agencies of the GNWT, with a special note going to the staff of the Legislative Assembly with whom we work closely on a daily basis.

---Applause

Mr. Speaker, there are many things happening in my constituency. Since the election, our community has been trying to promote unity of all residents. We have regular community leadership meetings, which include the band, Metis Nation, municipality and myself to plan and discuss a common direction for the community of Fort Smith. This sharing of information and concern helps us to focus our energies together for the benefit of the people in Smith on such areas as community empowerment and economic development. I have also met with groups and individuals in the community on a regular basis. It is very helpful to have feedback on what people want and need.

Mr. Speaker, the people of Fort Smith recognize the need for everyone to cut back and do their share. They accept this as long as it is fair and equitable among all residents and communities in the Northwest Territories. Mr. Speaker, my constituents are trying to diversify their economic base. There have been talks with BHP and hopefully with Kennecott in the near future. A group is looking at the revival of the buffalo ranch where, hopefully, the buffalo will once again roam. A local airline company is getting into speciality work and repairs of pontoons and other specialized equipment for planes. A two-man lumbering operation is getting off the ground. Mr. Speaker, Fort Smith is a government town. The key for us in these times of ongoing government restraint is to diversify our economy and draw on our economic base.

Mr. Speaker, my constituents are also concerned with the protection of the environment. They recognize the value of the land and want to see sustainable development. As a result, I will be working with this House and the appropriate Minister to ensure that this government responds to the northern river basin study which will be signed off early next month. I will also be following up with the Minister responsible on my questions about inventories and use of timber resources in the Northwest Territories.

Mr. Speaker, the decisions we have made to date as an Assembly have not been easy. Many long hours and sleepless nights have been spent by us all in the past months. The decisions we have made have been tough ones, but I believe we have honoured our commitment to fairness and sharing the pain and not doing it on the backs of the poor and less fortunate. I think we've lead by example with our seven per cent pay cut and a 60 per cent cut to our pensions. It's now imperative that we remain resolute and firm in carrying out our two-year deficit elimination plan. We owe it to the people of the Northwest Territories, especially the children.

Mr. Speaker, it's now time to turn our attention, efforts and combined skills and experience to dealing with the major social problems facing us all, as well as the critical need for private sector economic development. Over the coming summer months, we will all be busy so that, come October, when we reconvene, the people of the Northwest Territories will be able to clearly see progress on initiatives like economic development, empowerment, division and community wellness.

Mr. Speaker, when I became an MLA, I entered a different world; one which, like many others, I had many opinions on but little in-depth knowledge of. Like my colleague, Mr. Picco --who, I'd like to note as a sidebar at this point, was not in the office at 7:30 a.m. when I arrived this morning, was not in the office at 7:53 when Mr. Ng came in and we had coffee together; so, contrary to the sterling image that Mr. Picco is carefully crafting for himself, there may be some feet of clay here; he was here at, I believe, 8:03 a.m --when I arrived, I didn't know some of my colleagues. Some I knew by reputation, some I knew through my work or previous involvement in community politics, municipal politics, and some --five, to be exact --I've known since I was a smooth cheeked stripling; I was a lot thinner and had a lot more hair back then. I refer to Mr. Erasmus, Mr. Rabesca, Mr. Kakfwi, Mr. Antoine and Mr. Morin. I would like to especially acknowledge my friend and colleague, who sits to my immediate right. He and I first met after we were elected. His election picture was nothing at all like the real person. I value his friendship and, of course, his sage counsel.

Mr. Speaker, it is an honour to be serving with each and every one of my colleagues. I enjoy the spirit of give and take, the ideas and solutions that are generated as a result and, of course, the humour, which is an all-important factor, especially when dealing with the occasional absurdity that may bedevil us temporarily from time to time.

Mr. Speaker, I believe everyone has the best interests of their constituents and the NWT at heart when carrying out their duties as MLAs. If we continue to follow the path we've agreed to in the Agenda for Change, I believe we will be able to keep faith with those best interests in the days and months ahead.

In closing, Mr. Speaker, I would like to wish everyone a safe trip home, good hunting and a restful but productive summer. Thank you.

---Applause

Item 9: Replies To Opening Address
Item 9: Replies To Opening Address

Page 750

The Speaker Samuel Gargan

Thank you. Item 9, replies to Opening Address. Mr. Ootes.

Mr. Ootes's Reply

Item 9: Replies To Opening Address
Item 9: Replies To Opening Address

Page 752

Jake Ootes

Jake Ootes Yellowknife Centre

Qujannamiik, Liqaqfli. (Microphone turned off) month of our term and the time has passed extremely fast. I came in as a neophyte and, while I'm far from an expert, I am more experienced now. Like all the other MLAs, I jumped into the fray right at the start; I joined committees, I've diligently attended all sorts of briefing sessions, I've participated in the evolving of our mandate to govern, helping select a Premier and a Cabinet, reviewed the departmental business plans, et cetera. It's been a busy time. As a matter of fact, it's been too busy. The reality is we've done so much that it's been hard to find the time for

me to sit down and write about all the matters that I should review here. I will stick to those that are extremely important to me.

The Deficit

This has consumed six months of our time. I'm glad we have this budget out of the way because this has been all consuming and it is now time for us all to deal with economic development and opportunities. As the Minister of Finance knows, I'm not happy with the projected deficit elimination plan. It is my estimate that we will go into the new territories in 1999 with a deficit of $100 million. That is not acceptable to me. With the next budget, I will demand that the deficit be lowered.

Community Empowerment

While I am in agreement with empowering communities if they so desire, I'm of the opinion that community empowerment is a program that, over time, will be forced on communities. This was not the intent when it was first discussed. However, what I was told yesterday was that community empowerment is inevitable. It seems that eventually we will have only a skeleton public service to support those communities that do not want to run their own services. It is my opinion that community empowerment is fluff, with an implementation plan that has not been thoroughly thought out.

Accountability

Last week, I voted in favour of Ed Picco's motion to release all information on sole-source and negotiated contracts. To me, this motion was more than a symbolic gesture that we need more accountability and openness.

Business Incentive Policy

Affirmative Action

I have asked for this report consistently. It is too late now to debate this in this House during this session because I don't have the report. The affirmative action policy has some real problems with it. It doesn't work. It needs to be fixed. I have constituents who have encountered real problems because of this skewed policy. In order for us to deal with important issues like the BIP and affirmative action in this House, we need these reports. For me, these kinds of delays are not acceptable.

Constitution

We are in the process of designing a constitution for the Western Arctic. The time frame for the draft constitutional package will be about three months. I have been told and led to believe by all those who are participants in this process that, when it comes to ratification of the constitution, it will be put before the people of the Western Arctic on the basis of one person/one vote.

Mortgage Investment Corporation

I am aware of the need for housing in the North and the MIC is a means by which to solve some of these problems. However, I voted against the motion to approve funds for the MIC because, amongst all the things, I couldn't receive assurances that there would be long-term restrictions against use of this money for commercial loans.

MIA Compensation

The vehicles of communication in the Territories have been used over the past several months to comment about the MLA compensation package and the Report of the Commission on MLA Compensation. During my election campaign, there was one issue; that was MLA pensions. Since then, the number of issues seems to have grown to three: pensions, salaries and accountability. As Mrs. Groenewegen said earlier today, this matter will be deferred until the fall. However, I would like to say a few words with regard to salaries and pensions.

Two months ago, we rolled back our salaries and benefits by seven per cent. After the seven per cent roll-back, my salary is $55,413. I see we have an empty House just about, Mr. Speaker, but I am more than willing to carry on because I think other people will be listening.

---Applause

Hey, you folks out there, there are a lot of employees in these buildings who serve this government who make more than that, a lot more than that. The average Hay Plan employee is $82,736. I have 12 years of senior government administration experience and 20 years of business experience. If I had stayed in the government, I would be making more than $100,000 plus per year

---Applause

...because that's what the person who inherited my job was making when he retired. So, let me repeat that my salary is $55,413. In addition, I will probably make another $10,000 to $14,000 for committee work, for a total of $65,000 to $69,000. The Commission on MLA Compensation recommended a flat salary of $71,000, so I have accepted a salary less than the recommended amount.

I have changed my mind about payment for committee meetings. I think we should be remunerated for them. All Members sit on committees, some on two or three, plus extra ones like the constitution committees which seem to go on forever into the night. Those aren't paid for by anybody; we just volunteer for those. In the workforce, if you receive extra responsibilities or are required to work overtime, you get extra pay; whether you are a supervisor, a manager, an electrician, a plumber or a foreman. You get paid extra for over-time or extra responsibilities. Well, we get extra pay for committee work.

Item 9: Replies To Opening Address
Item 9: Replies To Opening Address

Page 752

Some Hon. Members

Hear! Hear!

Item 9: Replies To Opening Address
Item 9: Replies To Opening Address

Page 752

Jake Ootes

Jake Ootes Yellowknife Centre

In Ontario, Premier Mike Harris cut MLAs' salaries by 4.8 per cent, including benefits, to $88,865 from an estimated $93,389. Ontario Members get an average $24,000 more than I do, and our cost of living is 20 per cent higher.

---Applause

And the public should know that the work of an Ontario MLA is no different than ours. As a matter of fact, the workload is likely less because they have a lot more Members than we do. Here, we have to carry the load on all issues, each individual.

I got elected to put my experience to work, and work it is. The hours around here are no piece of cake. Ask the media representatives who work alongside of us here at the Legislative Assembly. Since I was elected, I have worked the straight eight months at least six days a week, 11 to 12 hours a day. On Sundays, I do my homework to catch up from the past week and prepare for the upcoming week, and I can vouch that everyone here puts in the same hours, some even more. It strains family relationships.

The job of an MLA is unlike any other trade or profession. Members must deal with an increasingly wide range of issues and concerns. The MLA must act as legislator, negotiator, ombudsman, social worker, public relations officer and perform many of the tasks at all hours of the day and night. It is a demanding vocation. I have been required to become an expert on financial restraint, government operations, aboriginal concerns, constitutional development, division of the NWT, affirmative action, business incentive policy, municipal governments, school boards, hospitals, social agencies, chambers of commerce and various volunteer organizations. In addition, I must represent my constituents in a multitude of ways and resolve all kinds of problems.

This job is a huge invasion of our privacy. People expect us to be on call 24 hours a day. Every time there is a raffle ticket to be sold, we get asked to buy some. If constituents have a problem, they come to us. Let me tell you what happened to me two weeks ago; it happened to four MLAs from Yellowknife two weeks ago. A local organization sent us a fax two days prior to a meeting, inviting us to attend, and when I say us, I specifically mean me. I telephoned that organization and left a message that I had committed two months previously to attend another function that night. I asked that my apologies be passed on and that it would be mentioned at the meeting that I could not attend. The day after the meeting, a newspaper report complained that no Yellowknife MLAs attended. Even the editorial referred to our lack of attendance. I phoned the executive director and asked why we were singled out. Well, she hadn't checked her messages until the day after the meeting. I am here to serve. I will attend meetings when invited but, please understand, our schedules, from time to time, may conflict.

When I made a representation to the commission on MLAs' salaries, here is part of what I told them when they asked about salaries: "Many undertake public life at considerable personal sacrifice to themselves and their families. There is no job security. The workload is ever increasing. This Assembly will be busier than any previous one. Some serve at financial cost to themselves as a result of loss of income that may have been derived from business, professional practice or service with government in some senior administrative capacity, and many put their careers on hold while serving in public office.'

"The cost of living in the North is much higher than such places as Ottawa, Toronto, Victoria and Edmonton. Therefore, a comparison of MLAs' salaries and pensions should reflect the higher cost of living."

With regard to the matter of pensions, we have eliminated the supplementary benefit that was in place. That was the portion that the public had a problem with. In essence, what we have done is reduce our pensions by 60 per cent. With regard to the report of the Commission on MLA Compensation, the major recommendations dealing with salaries and pensions have already been dealt with. It has been made clear to me that many Members need the time to look carefully at the recommendations and how they fit in with the new way the Assembly has been operating.

I want to thank the staff of the Legislative Assembly and of the various departments that appeared before us in committee meetings and so forth, for their dedication and all the hard work that they've put in. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Mahsi cho.

---Applause

Item 9: Replies To Opening Address
Item 9: Replies To Opening Address

Page 752

The Speaker Samuel Gargan

Thank you, Mr. Ootes. Item 9, replies to Opening Address. Mr. Roland.

Mr. Roland's Reply

Item 9: Replies To Opening Address
Item 9: Replies To Opening Address

Page 753

Floyd Roland

Floyd Roland Inuvik

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Mr. Speaker, honourable Members, I would like to start by saying that this has been an education of its own. I came here with my eyes and ears open and my back to the wall. I came here with ideas given to me by the people of Inuvik. Some were accepted, some not.

Mr. Speaker, the main theme of ideas from the people of Inuvik was to change the way government does business. I believe that we have begun to do some changes, but many will still say it is not enough. There have been areas where we've started to do changes, Mr. Speaker. I would like to say that it seems that this 13th Assembly has come into a time of heavy skies, where the sun is hidden with the grey clouds of change.

There has been talk about division in this Assembly. I want to speak about division, but from a different angle. I want to talk about unity. I'm concerned that we're focusing too much on the things that make us different: East versus West, Dene versus Inuit, native versus non-native. The financial situation we are in is one reason why this is happening. The days when the government could throw money around are gone for good. We have limited financial resources, but also unlimited needs and problems. The budget process has really brought home to me how difficult the situation is. It is troubling to know that we can't keep one program without taking money away from some other program, and it's easy to understand how we can be at odds with each other when we're contending for pieces of a smaller pie.

The process of division is another area where people are being tempted into debating differences, rather than cooperating. The federal government has told us about the money that is available for infrastructure in Nunavut, they are telling us who should manage the capital projects. Groups in the Western Arctic are debating self-government, regional government, treaty rights and western constitutional development. I know we are supposed to debate and discuss important issues here and I know that all 24 of us are never going to agree on every single issue, but we have to rise above petty things, we have to rise above the concepts of "not in my back yard" and "my need is greater than yours.` We have to set an example of working together for the good of all northerners. Each one of us represents a portion of the 65,000 residents of the Northwest Territories; male, female, native, non-native. We will disagree and we will debate, but we have to work together. In many ways, we have done that and we are going to do that. But our goal has to be to make all of our decisions and our statements geared towards the issue of what is best for northerners.

In less than three years, division of the NWT will happen and we will probably be in the middle of two election campaigns. There is so much work to be done between now and then. It seems that very little is actually being done.

Mr. Speaker, we are quickly coming up to a point in the road where there is a bridge. We have to decide whether we are going to cross and how we will cross this bridge. As we are debating the ideas of how to get to the other side, we must be cautious of what is happening around us or behind us. Timing is also of significance here, because if we look back, coming down the same road is a truck built by the feds. It's big and its brakes don't seem to be working.

We need an interim Commissioner for Nunavut. We need an electoral boundaries commission in the East and the West. We need to start the process of revising our laws and statutes. We need to have a concrete set of proposals of how to govern the Western Territory after division. We need formula financing agreements with Ottawa that will ensure that both Territories will have sufficient resources to meet the needs of the northern residents.

Mr. Speaker, I do not mean to sound so pessimistic. In fact, I do see a number of examples of unity and togetherness around me, and I am grateful for those. The people of

Nunavut, for example, are more and more excited as we draw closer to the reality of their vision of their own territory. The dream of being in control of their own affairs is motivating them as nothing else can.

In the West, we are seeing the development of a partnership between western MLAs and the aboriginal leaders to advance the constitutional development of the Western Territory. We are also seeing the unity in the naming of the Western Territory. In fact, of all those who put forward suggestions of the name for the Western Territory, approximately 90 per cent, along with leaders in my region, agree on a single choice. Such togetherness is almost unheard of nowadays. Moreover, their choice will mean it will save a lot of money. We won't have to reprint stationary or change signs if we do keep the name "Northwest Territories."

Let's not contend among ourselves --and I've referred to the Good Book before and I'll do so again --the Good Book says avoid foolish questions and contentions for they are unprofitable and vain. Mr. Speaker, let's put petty differences aside. Let's use the time, talents and energy we have to work together to solve our problems, to take care of each other and build two new territories that will be places where northerners. can see their dreams come true.

In closing, Mr. Speaker, the 13th Assembly might still have a chance to see the clouds break and the sun once again shine on the people of the North. Mr. Speaker, it has been somewhat of a pleasure to be here during the initial number of months, but I will definitely be glad to get back home and hold my children once more. Thank you.

---Applause

Item 9: Replies To Opening Address
Item 9: Replies To Opening Address

Page 753

The Speaker Samuel Gargan

Thank you. Item 9, replies to Opening Address. Mr. Antoine.

Hon. Jim Antoine's Reply

Item 9: Replies To Opening Address
Item 9: Replies To Opening Address

Page 754

Jim Antoine Nahendeh

(Translation) Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I will be speaking to you for a while in my language today. Today, it seems like the Legislative Assembly will be proroguing, so I would like to leave a brief message with you. We, sitting here in the Northwest Territories, are from a lot of different places. Some people have been born here in the Northwest Territories; some are Inuit, some are Dene, some are Metis and some are from up north, Inuvialuit, and other people from other places in Canada and others from other foreign countries. But we are sitting here together and working together. For that, I would like to thank you.

This is the message I would like to talk to you about. Today, I would like to talk to you about the perspective of Dene. I grew up as a Dene and so I would like to talk to you in the perspective of a Dene. Dene people are born in the North. In my case, I grew up in the country with my relatives. A lot of Dene people grew up that way. From the first time I can remember, we had a lot of white people starting to live on our land.

In 1921, when there was a treaty, it was only a peace treaty. On the side of government, there were a lot of arrangements that had been agreed to, such as housing, education, rations and social assistance. These were the items that were promised at the time. So all our relatives were told that at the time. Since then, it seems like it was changing every year. In our communities, a lot of things were changing; on our land, our region and all over the North.

When things started changing here in the North, it seemed to be without the involvement of the Dene people. They didn't have any involvement. When there was a government that we didn't agree to, we had some input but we hadn't been taken seriously. Since the beginning of the Government of the Northwest Territories, it seems that they are becoming more prominent. So we know how the Government of the Northwest Territories is now.

We have names for the features on our land, such as rivers and mountains. We named all these land features in our language; but when the white people came on our land, all the places that we had names for, they gave different names to. So when you say "Deh Cho," they have renamed it to "Mackenzie River." There is a mountain close to Fort Simpson that is called "Beaver Hills." That was renamed to "Abbot Hills." The Horn Plateau we called "Horn Mountain." The Liard River we called " Nachahdeh." Since ancient times, we have had names for these places. Our community of Fort Simpson was called "Liidlii Kue." Fort Wrigley was called "Tthedzeh Kue," Fort Providence was called, "Zhahti Kue," Trout Lake was called "Sombaa K'e" and Fort Liard was called "Lateke" and Hay River was called "Katlodehe," and Jean Marie River was called "Tlhek'ehdel." We had names for communities and land features on our land. What I'm saying is that we, as Dene, have names for our land.

First, when the government started coming up this way, they did not listen to us. This was kind of classified as colonial mentality. When they came up here, they governed the land as they did in their land. So Fort Franklin was renamed to Deline; and Fort Norman is Tulita; Snowdrift went back to the Dene name of Lutsel K'e. So the Dene people have renamed some of their communities to their original name.

When we first started calling ourselves the way we call ourselves, "Dene," it was hard. When the white people first came up here, we were called Indians. The organization, the Indian Brotherhood, was renamed the Dene Nation, as well. So when you change things, it's hard. The word that we used to classify ourselves was Dene, and we expressed that it would be good if they called us Dene. When that was done, we used the letterhead of Dene. At the time, the Indian Brotherhood was in existence.

There are other lands that have started recognizing us. Now when people hear the term "Dene Nation" they know what it is about. In that way, when we changed the name to Dene people, they saw us as constructive. When the English word of NWT is used, a lot of Dene people do not understand what it means.

When the Northwest Territories came into existence, it was part of the other provinces, such as Manitoba, Saskatchewan, Alberta, Yukon and Northwest Territories. Therefore, when the older Dene people heard the term "Northwest Territories" they did not know what it meant. Now we will have another piece chopped off:

Nunavut; and we are the leftovers. When you say Nunavut in the Inuit language, it means "our land," and I'm thankful that they named it that way. When we are searching for a name, I don't think we should be called "NWT." What I would like to say is, when the Dene people hear the word "NWT," they don't know what it means.

I grew up along the Mackenzie in the area called Rabbit Skin River. When I was growing up, my relatives didn't know what the word "NWT" meant. When we talked about our land, it was the way it meant, in our language, "our land." This way it was recognized by the Dene people. When the Dene people started getting involved in politics, it seemed like the NWT was imposed on us as well as the government system. So when we say the Northwest Territories, in Dene we are saying it; interpreted back it would mean "cold land" or "cold place." This is how you would say the Northwest Territories to the Dene people, in my language. So I didn't feel the word "Northwest Territories" was relevant to Dene people and that is why I am saying this. Also, the Dene languages such as Chipewyan, Dogrib and the Sahtu, all say the words "cold land" or "cold place" in their language. They don't say "Northwest Territories."

So when the Chipewyan people talk about the Northwest Territories, the way they say it is translated back as "cold land." I would just like to express that. There are many people who are Metis, Dene, Inuvialuit and when they stay within their community, maybe if we talked about this to them, they would probably agree with what I said. That is why I am saying this to you in my language today.

Many of the MLAs probably understand their language. If they are going to rename the western NWT, it would be good to listen to the Dene people's suggestions. I am just saying to continue using the name "NWT" doesn't sound suitable to me. This is why I am saying this in my language. This is what I would like to say at the moment. Thank you.

---Applause

Item 9: Replies To Opening Address
Item 9: Replies To Opening Address

Page 754

The Speaker Samuel Gargan

Mahsi, Mr. Antoine. Item 9, replies to Opening Address, Mr. Barnabas.

Mr. Barnabas's Reply

Item 9: Replies To Opening Address
Item 9: Replies To Opening Address

Page 759

Levi Barnabas High Arctic

(Translation) Thank you, Mr. Speaker. (Translation ends) ...my reply to Opening Address with some good news. I am referring to outstanding achievements of my constituents.

My first credit goes to Tudjaat, an outstanding new musical group, composed of Madeline Allakariallak and Phoebe Atagotaaluk.

What happened was, in the winter of 1994, Susan Aglukark was in Resolute Bay to do some recording for her hit album, "This Child." Susan was looking for some back-up for the new recording and asked her producer, Randall Prescott, to come to Resolute to see what they could find. Madeline Allakariallak was then part of the local theatre group of about 20 people, called "Takiualuk" and they recorded pisiq -- which is traditional Inuit singing --for the producer.

As Mr. Prescott said in an interview in a recent issue of Above and Beyond: "One voice in my headphones stood out. Who is this angel, I asked myself." That was Madeline. Madeline, who is 20, grew up in Resolute Bay, cared for mainly by her grandmother, Minnie, who is now 80. "She's put so much into me," said Madeline in the article, "I love my grandmother so much." It was Minnie who taught her granddaughter throat-singing. Madeline's cousin, Phoebe Atagotaaluk, from Inukjuak was also in the theatre group. She and Madeline teamed up and learned throat-singing from Minnie.

Soon after that visit, Randall Prescott invited Madeline to participate in the concert he was helping to organize in Whitehorse. Phoebe was very excited because Tom Jackson, the singer and the television star of North of 60, was going to be there. Madeline and Phoebe opened the show with some throat-singing and then Madeline sang her translation of "You are My Sunshine" and an old pisiq, called "Qiugaviit." The crowd loved it. Phoebe was thrilled when someone asked for her autograph.

Madeline says she will always remember Tom Jackson's advice to her: "Don't let this go to your head."

Tudjaat has just had their first album released by Sony Canada. Recently, they performed for the Canadian Aboriginal Achievement Awards, televised right across Canada. But there is no sign that success has gone to their heads, They are having fun, keeping everything in perspective and hoping their example somehow helps others. Mr. Speaker, I am sure it will.

"We just want people to enjoy our music." Taking Tom Jackson's advice to heart, the girls say they aren't expecting anything big out of their music.

However, the music and the message is getting big. One song that has everyone's attention is the heart-rending story of Minnie's relocation in 1953, along with 84 other Inuit; from Inukjuak in Northern Quebec, to the High Arctic. Madeline says she wants all of Canada and the world to know what her grandmother went through.

It seems the world may soon know the story. The video of the album, which is called "My Ship Comes In"' was released with great fanfare in early February on the New Country Network, which attracts four million in Canada alone and reaches most of the globe by satellite.

Even though it talks about the great hardship of those people, the song has a hopeful message. It was called "Kajusita," which means to keep looking forward, to sail on. The song is about taking the pain from the relocation and going forward stronger.

These hit tunes are quite extraordinary because they incorporate traditional Inuit forms of music, throat-singing and pisiq. When this is mixed with pop music, the mix of traditional and pop is very different and pleasing. Madeline's grandmother is very happy that throat-singing is being heard.

This winter, just after their video, CD and cassette package was being released in North America, they flew to Europe for a series of performances. Then a person working in the Canadian Embassy in Tokyo presented the album to Japanese government officials who liked it so much that they have invited the two young women to come to Japan later this year.

I am very proud of these two young constituents of mine who are doing well and so far have not let their success go to their heads. They are an example for people who are rooted in Inuit culture and are strong and self-assured because of that. I believe that, as we move towards Nunavut, we must hold strong to our culture and values and the wisdom of our elders like Minnie Allakariallak. They have much to teach us if we are willing to learn.

Another musical group in my constituency has taken Baffin by storm. They are called Tuniit. They are from my home town and I am very proud of them. There is Lucas Attagutsiak, band leader; Harry lyerak, manager/singer; Noah Qaqqasiq, vocals and instruments; and, Lucy Qaqqasiq, singer. With help from Economic Development and Tourism and Canadian Airlines, they have produced their first CD, called "Ikajunga." Qimiuksiqti is a favourite song in Kuujuaq, where they are the favourite performers at events like lqaluit's Toonik Tyme.

I also want to salute Peter Flaherty for his outstanding achievement in being made NWT volunteer of the year.

---Applause

As I said earlier, Peter is the kind of person you would love to have as your neighbour; always looking for ways to help and be useful. Peter Flaherty, who was born and grew up with very hard times with the people who were relocated near Grise Fiord in 1953, is an example of what Madeline's song told about: a person who has become generous and kind, not angry, in spite of great hardship as a child. This is a great tribute to his parents.

I would like to thank the Minister of MACA for assisting Peter's mother and sister to be here with him when he receives the great honour, and Members of this Assembly for showing their respect to this very humble constituent of mine. I know he will be a good example for all of us. Thank you for letting me tell these good things about my wonderful constituents from Resolute Bay, Arctic Bay and Grise Fiord.

Now I want to talk about some of my constituents' concerns. I have spoken about this already in length in this Assembly in my reply to Budget Address, so I will not go over that detail again. However, I do believe that many of our most unfortunate constituents are hurting. I speak about elders and those who must be on social assistance.

I would like to give my full support to the efforts of my colleague, Mr. Enuaraq, who introduced a motion to review the monthly territorial old-age supplement. I also spoke on the need of a review on social assistance rates, especially the food allowance. If we are to support families in need, they must have enough money to feed their families properly. The food allowance should reflect the actual cost of living in each community. Where I live, food is very expensive.

I am looking forward to the results of the review which Mr. Dent has promised to undertake on this issue. I am very encouraged that it was Mr. Dent, as the chairman of the Special Committee on Health and Social Services, who introduced the motion in the previous Assembly very similar to the one introduced in Committee of the Whole during this session. In fact, I believe the wording is almost identical. Mr. Dent knows what it is like to be an ordinary Member to make a motion and then hope that it is acted upon by Cabinet. I know he will do his best to see that these needs are addressed in the future.

I also mentioned that I see two different points of view which exist, even amongst the federal government departments, about the issue of new national parks and land use by Cominco on Bathurst Island. Since I made the statement about that in this House, I learned that one of my constituents have been working hard on this issue. I am anxious to learn of his views and am looking forward to getting a briefing from the Honourable Stephen Kakfwi, who is involved with this issue through several of his present portfolios; Energy, Mines and Petroleum Resources and Renewable Resources. I am looking forward to learning more about the important issues in the future.

I also want to repeat my earlier open invitation to the Honourable Jim Antoine to visit my constituency to meet the mayor, the council and the community leaders in Resolute Bay. We are anxious to learn more about the exciting plans for the new airport terminal and to find out how the community might benefit from this project. I believe there are quite a number of economic opportunities which could create new jobs for northern residents. I look forward to working with Mr. Antoine and His Worship Mayor George Eckalook, and take advantage of these new business and employment opportunities. I believe that if you are involved in planning from the beginning, the project will be a great success.

I also want to thank the Minister for his very informative statement about NavCan, made yesterday. Mr. Speaker, I mentioned earlier in this session my concern that our Government should be fully involved in the transfer of responsibility of all Arctic flight service stations to NavCan this year. I was therefore very pleased to hear Mr. Antoine's statement yesterday; first that, to its credit, Transport Canada has conducted extensive consultations with the many parties who have an interest in commercialization.

Secondly, the GNWT Department of Transportation participated fully in consultations representing our interests. I am very happy that the bill now before Parliament includes special provisions for northern or remote services. If NavCan should propose to reduce northern or remote services, the bill spells out the very strict consultation process, which includes the provincial and territorial government of the affected area. Also, if there is an objection to the reduction in service from our government, the Minister of Transportation can veto the change. The bill also says the fee charges for northern remote services must not be any higher than comparable fees in other parts of Canada.

I was also encouraged to hear Mr. Antoine say that it is possible that we may have even better air navigation services with NavCan than before. They are more likely to use the latest technology. I believe we have a great interest in having the most modern, reliable and accurate air navigation services where we live in Nunavut. We have no choice but to fly. There are no highways from southern Canada in parts of Nunavut.

I am pleased that the Minister will be watching carefully for our interests and I am very much looking forward to being present when he explains what is happening to my constituents in Resolute Bay. I would like to thank Mr. Antoine for responding to the concern raised by the hamlet of Resolute Bay. The hamlet of Resolute Bay expressed their concern to me that sometimes they have trouble clearing the road to the airport, especially after bad weather. Even if the airport runway is clear, they said it isn't much use for us if we can't move goods from the town to the airport. They asked the airport manager about using one of the airport's snowblowers, but they were told it can't be done.

Meanwhile, I found out that MACA's capital standards don't include snowblowers, for hamlets, so I asked Mr. Antoine if he could help. I just got his written reply yesterday and, in that reply, Mr. Antoine explained to me that the two snowblowers, located in the Resolute Bay airport are very ancient Idaho Norland snowblowers, The models are no longer made and spare parts are very expensive and hard to get. Both are still working, but the Minister explained to me that the eventual plan is for the older machine of the two to be used for spare parts for the newer machine. The department believes that, by carefully looking after the maintenance of these old machines, there is another five to 10 years of life left. So Mr. Antoine explained, because these machines are old, it would be best to use them only for emergency situations where the airport snowblower is the only way of dealing with the problem. Mr. Antoine asks that the community otherwise use their own equipment for routine clearing of snow. This is a reasonable solution, Mr. Speaker. I also want to thank the Minister for his very informative Mr. Speaker, I know that the mayor was very happy to receive Mr. Antoine's response; so was I. Government should be fully involved in the transfer of I believe that the transfer of our airports to the GNWT last year, the new terminal building and the establishment of NavCan all represent opportunities for our communities. We expect to have new training and employment opportunities, especially for our young people. We hope to have more involvement in what goes on at the airport. This will be the major project for my constituency in the life of this Assembly, and I will hope to be fully involved in making sure the new terminal is built according to its schedule.

I want to mention another very important capital project which was voted money during this past session, and thank Members for their support; that is, the Baffin Regional Hospital for my constituents. Even though they are many miles away, the Baffin Regional Hospital in lqaluit is the nearest major medical facility. For example, Grise Fiord is 900 miles away from lqaluit. My constituents depend very much on that hospital and on hospitals in Montreal. This hospital is old, and it is not appropriate to the needs of our very large region. We have the largest geographical area and the largest population of any of the regions, and our population is growing fast. The new hospital will meet our present and future needs and should allow us to take care of more of our sick people in the North, rather than having to send them far away to Montreal. This trend will save us money as well, as Stanton Regional Hospital has shown. I believe the same needs exist in the Inuvik region, as well.

Now that we are getting so close to Nunavut, I want to mention a point that I have been making in this session to Mr. Dent, the Minister of Education, Culture and Employment. I am pleased that Mr. Dent agrees with me that our government, through Arctic College and divisional boards of education, should be given responsibility to provide the training for Nunavut, using our existing schools and community learning centres. Mr. Speaker, I believe that everyone agrees that training is the key to the success of getting northern residents involved in the government of Nunavut. I am confident that, when we discuss this issue, the Nunavut Implementation Commission --which has recommended this already in Footprints in the New Snow -- and Nunavut Tungavik will agree that this is the fastest way of getting much-needed training started as soon as possible. In that connection, I would urge Mr. Dent to make sure that the human resources development plan, which is now well under way, is completed on time and is put in place as soon as possible.

Since we are seeing some existing Arctic College programs, moving out of one of the regions into another, I would hope that these new monies could be used to make sure that every region of Nunavut has available to it important college programs like human resource services and management training, as soon as possible. This is a very important program. Those graduates, I am sure, will be very much needed in Nunavut.

The benefits to government --through such activities as delivery of education programs to many communities from a single location; remote diagnosis and treatment of patients through telemedicine; and, the reduction of travel costs through the use of video conferencing --will result in considerable savings, as well as improving the quality of service and the program delivery. People in the communities, for instance, could take university courses at home without having to go south, and northern people could teach aboriginal language and traditional language courses to southern students. Treatment and diagnosis through telemedicine could reduce medical travel costs and speed patient recovery by allowing people to remain in their home communities.

Maybe MLAs could even participate in Caucus or committee meetings from their home communities. I know I sometimes have to wait over the weekend in lqaluit to get home to Arctic Bay, or leave on Friday to attend a Monday meeting in Yellowknife. I would certainly welcome the opportunity to participate by video conference, especially if it was a way to hold a short meeting.

The GNWT and municipal governments could market themselves as a tourist destination through the simple use of Home Pages on the Internet, which is currently being done by many governments around the world.

Mr. Speaker, these are just a few of the opportunities to access from the information highway state-of-the-art telecommunications infrastructure can provide. A broadband telecommunications system, once it is in place, can also benefit the private business sector and private organizations, and the individual, in both public and private sectors, could use the same system at a little extra cost. All that is required is a satellite dish of the right size connected to the computers in each community. With such a system, businesses would be able to communicate effectively with businesses in other communities. Private citizens would be able to work for territorial and federal government and the private sector from their home communities; saving relocation and workspace dollars as well as the pain associated with relocation. Aboriginal organizations would be able to hold meetings through the use of video conferencing. This would save some money associated with travel costs which, in turn, could be put into pursuing economic development opportunities in their home communities. ahead with a 384-kilobauds-per-second broadband However, making sure that the private businesses, aboriginal organizations and individuals have access to the modern day telecommunications first requires overcoming a number of barriers. In the first place, as Mr. Todd knows, the broadband system is required. Without one, none of these activities are possible. In the second place, the copper wire used in telephone connections to individual homes and businesses, in many cases, is not good enough to allow access to the information highway. Upgrading the copper wire in all the communities to fibre-optic wire would cost too much money, even if the copper wire were to be upgraded. The services necessary to access the Internet do not exist, except in the larger centres. Even if all the infrastructure and services were to exist, a lot of our people could not benefit from this because they are not familiar with the computers. Even if they did know how to use the system, many people could not afford to buy computers or pay the long-distance charges. Also, some people cannot write in English.

The Nunavut Implementation Commission has advocated the construction of what they call "community teleservice centres" as a means of overcoming these barriers. They will require a broadband telecommunications system, which Mr. Todd has announced will be put to a proposal call. The centres will be staffed by bilingual employees and they could be used to meet the needs of both the public and private sectors. These community teleservice centres could be the perfect way to train public servants and private sector individuals in the use of computer and information technology. As well, they could serve as locations for video conferences for anyone. These teleservice centres could be placed in existing facilities such as schools, hamlet offices, recreational centres or community learning centres. In the case of Nunavut, a space could be allocated for them in a new or existing government building.

If teleservice centres were equipped with child care facilities, single parents could take training and use them as places of work. Teleservice centres could serve as locations where people could find out information about government programs and services, apply for a new driver's licence, get birth certificates, et cetera. The teleservice centres could serve as electronic polling stations. Residents could take computer training and operate a small business using these facilities. In other words, Mr. Speaker, community teleservice centres could assist in creating new jobs and business opportunities in our smaller and more remote communities.

In my opinion, these community teleservice centres could be the key to making community transfer and community empowerment work better, by giving our communities the tools for the very best and most cost-effective communications system available today. This could mean that a lot of business and work could be done at the community level. Government public servants would not have to visit us as much and we would not have to travel to a regional centre or Yellowknife to talk about and solve problems.

The best thing about these teleservice centres is that they would allow people to work through the computer without having to leave their home community. I believe that when these teleservice centres are put into our communities, they could create new job opportunities throughout Nunavut in all of our smaller communities.

Mr. Speaker, I know that in the province of New Brunswick, the Premier of New Brunswick, through his vision, established the necessary technological support and properly trained bilingual workforce to have many national and even international companies establish teleservice centres for their customers. When you can call to do your banking or pay your bills by telephone, as you can do from most parts of the NWT, you may be speaking to a person on the other end of the line who is from a rural community in New Brunswick.

I believe we can do the same in Nunavut. With some basic training in computer literacy, I believe that there are a lot of routine government functions that could be done in our small communities by local people, where many people are fluent in both English and lnuktitut.

In this reply, I am hoping to draw the attention of all MLAs to these exciting potentials in Nunavut because, if we make it work in Nunavut, I think it could be made to work in the Western Arctic as well. I will be asking our government if it has a view of the proposed telecommunications; and, whether, working with NIC, NTI and the Government of Canada, Nunavut implementation funds could be applied to setting up the basic community infrastructure to establish telecommunications in Nunavut.

I know that there are costs to all of this, as outlined in the NIC report; however, in today's society where knowledge is power, the NWT will be left behind without a broadband telecommunication system and access to the information highway. I know, just because you have access to information technology, that will not automatically create jobs and economic opportunities but they will be necessary for the economic development and growth.

Two recent papers have been prepared by the Nunavut Implementation Commission. One is about the social and economic benefits of the community teleservice centres. The other paper explains how they could be designed and what they would cost. The papers are very useful. I understand they have been given to our government and I will table one paper, the Nunavut Telecommunication Needs: Community Teleservice Centres, later today.

Mr. Speaker, one of the main reasons I am supporting the Finance Minister's initiative to establish a new wider broadband for telecommunications and the NIC report for the community teleservice centres is that I believe in community transfer and community empowerment. However, our communities will need lots of support, advice and assistance when they are taking on new responsibilities. I would like to see more government programs delivered at the local level; however, Mr. Speaker, if my constituents are going to apply for their birth certificate, health care card or driver's licence, they must be connected to the department of the territorial government. If they are managing construction projects, delivering other programs --like housing, health and social services, for example --they need close communication with the department on whose behalf they are providing these services.

I'm committed to community transfer and community empowerment, but the most modern communication system must be in place soon if it is going to work well. I also believe that if we are to have a decentralized government in Nunavut, the community teleservice centres will be the most effective way of setting up the new government services, as well.

If local people can do their jobs in the community teleservice centres or on their home terminal, then there may be a lesser need for costly new office facilities. I believe that these modern facilities, along with the new approach to how work is done in Nunavut, will make it possible to create jobs in the new Nunavut government. In my communities, outside the regional centres, perhaps even in a very small communities like those I represent, it wouldn't require a lot of workspace to do certain jobs. With training in computer skills, local people could do these jobs instead of having to move out of their community to find work. Perhaps some people could even work on their own time and at their own convenience. Whenever it is convenient for them to get access to the teleservice centres, most people might be able to even work at home.

Mr. Speaker, I know that this has been a long reply to the Commissioner's Address, but I have been looking for the opportunity to discuss the important subject of the community teleservice centres. I do not believe that it has to cost a lot of money to establish jobs in our small communities, especially if we can use the latest technology and if we look at different ways in which people can work in the 1990s. The workplace is changing everywhere else. With Nunavut and the new Western Territory, we have great opportunity to modernize and do things differently. It might just cost less money than the old ways, as well.

I wish to commend Mr. Todd for his initiative and urge him to take the next step and find a way to build community teleservice centres in our communities once the critical broadband width has been in place. I will also be working to encourage the federal government, NIC and NTI to recognize that our smaller communities will greatly benefit from this new technology. It will be good for business, employment and successful operation of the local and territorial levels of the government.

Mr. Speaker, establishing community teleservice centres will be the means of helping our people overcome barriers to economic growth and job creation. This development is especially important for the smaller, more remote communities like the ones I represent. Mr. Speaker, the information highway is our future, especially in our remote communities, and we must invest in it.

Mr. Speaker, in closing, I hope all the Members will have a well-deserved rest from a long meeting in this building in favour of being with families and constituents at home. It has been a very long session and I am looking forward to being out on the land with my family and visiting my constituents. I would like to express my very great thanks to the interpreters for the very good job they have done for us all; to the pages from the schools around here; to the very capable Clerk and his staff at the Legislative Assembly; our committee clerks, especially Mr. Schauerte; our faithful executive secretary, Ms. Betty Low, who, I know, always has a challenging time with my travel arrangements; and all the other good people who worked so hard with us in this Assembly. Finally, I wish to thank you, Mr. Speaker, and our very kind chairs of Committee of the Whole who helped us in this House to do its work in a fair and respectable manner. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Have a good summer. Have a good rest.

---Applause

Item 9: Replies To Opening Address
Item 9: Replies To Opening Address

Page 759

The Speaker Samuel Gargan

Thank you, Mr. Barnabas. We will take a 15-minute break.

---SHORT RECESS

Item 9: Replies To Opening Address
Item 9: Replies To Opening Address

Page 759

The Speaker Samuel Gargan

The House will come back to order. We are on item 9, replies to Opening Address. Mr. Erasmus.

Mr. Erasmus's Reply

Item 9: Replies To Opening Address
Item 9: Replies To Opening Address

Page 760

Roy Erasmus Yellowknife North

Mr. Speaker, I haven't had time to work on a stirring and passionate speech like some of our other Members here. The last couple of weeks, I have been busy working on amendments to the Motor Vehicles Act, trying to get my research and the rest of that in place. As a matter of fact, I have had to work so much on it that I've been dreaming about headlights on our roads for the last couple of weeks.

I have also been working from 9:00 a.m. to approximately 9:00 p.m. or 10:00 p.m. every night. We leave here about that time, go home, spend a little bit of time with our families and then try to deal with constituents' problems. So I haven't really had much time to prepare, but I do have a few brief comments.

I also appreciate the hard work and dedication of the staff of the Legislative Assembly.

---Applause

I would like to thank the staff for all their assistance and, particularly, those who helped me with my work on the amendment to the headlights bill. Mr. Speaker, I just wanted to comment a little bit about comments made by my fellow MLA, Mr. Ootes, indicating how much work the MLAs do. In the last little while, we've been getting here at 9:00 a.m.; sometimes 8:00 a.m., depending on how much work has to be done. From there, it's one meeting after another all day. You go from one meeting to another, and even during lunch time you have a meeting. We meet all day and, at supper time, it's another meeting. We've been finishing here at 8:30 at night, but I usually try to answer letters and the rest of that, so I am here until 9:00 p.m. or 10:00 p.m.

Mr. Speaker, I wanted to indicate that I am still learning, and I look forward to coming back in the fall with this new experience under my belt. We have now gone through one budget. We will be looking at another budget in the tall, and I hope that my past experience will help me and the other new MLAs to do a better job. We will now know what questions to ask and what to look for, rather than it just being a learning experience.

Mr. Speaker, I would like to close be reiterating Mr. Roland's words: "We are all hard-working people here; MLAs. We all want what's best for our constituents, but it's now time to forget our petty differences. It's now time to concentrate on what's best for our constituents. It's now time to look at what's best for the NWT and to work hard for that. " Mahsi.

---Applause

Item 9: Replies To Opening Address
Item 9: Replies To Opening Address

Page 760

The Speaker Samuel Gargan

Thank you, Mr. Erasmus. Item 9, replies to Opening Address. Item 10, petitions. Mrs. Groenewegen.

Item 10: Petitions
Item 10: Petitions

May 28th, 1996

Page 760

Jane Groenewegen

Jane Groenewegen Hay River

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I have a petition that I would like to table in the House today in my capacity as the chairperson of the Subcommittee of Western Caucus for the renaming of the Northwest Territories. That is the capacity in which I have received this petition. Petition 51-13(3) will indicate to Mr. Antoine and Mr. Kakfwi exactly the amount of work that has to be done. I heard both of their speeches here in the House; Mr. Antoine, today, and Mr. Kakfwi's. I would like to read the petition and then indicate the communities where these petitions come from and the numbers.

"In the matter of a petition to the Government of the Northwest Territories, in the matter of a petition to the Government of Canada by the residents of the western portion of the Northwest Territories, we, the undersigned, hereby petition the governments of the Northwest Territories and Canada to maintain the designation Northwest Territories for the Western Arctic after division in 1999. The designation has served the North and western portions of Canada throughout our modern history and carries with it that history and international recognition of which we, as residents of the Northwest Territories, are justly proud.

"Further, we believe that any change to this designation will result in needless expenditure, discord and international isolation. The Northwest Territories is our home, and we want it to remain as such."

These pages contain signatures from residents of Fort Smith, Norman Wells, Hay River, Inuvik, Fort Simpson and, in total, come to 1,637. Further, I would just like to say that it isn't a decided thing yet, and Mr. Kakfwi wants me to say that with the people he has spoken to personally, he has made progress, and we recognize that. Thank you.

Item 10: Petitions
Item 10: Petitions

Page 760

The Speaker Samuel Gargan

Again, I would like to remind the Members that the rules are very clear with regard to petitions. You don't make general comments on them. You don't try to debate on the petition. The purpose of a petition is to send a message through the government, and you read that petition as such and then you give the amount of signatures on the petition. I would like to ask the Members not to make comments on a petition. Item 10, petitions. Mr. Henry.

Item 10: Petitions
Item 10: Petitions

Page 760

Seamus Henry Yellowknife South

Thank you, Mr. Speaker. I have three petitions. The first one: I would like to present a petition dealing with the matter of the naming of the new western territory after division. Mr. Speaker, Petition 52-13(3) contains three signatures, and it alleges that the Government of the Northwest Territories retain the Northwest Territories as a name when two separate territories are formed in 1999.

The second petition, Mr. Speaker, deals with funding for community wellness youth programs in the city of Yellowknife. Mr. Speaker, Petition 53-13(3) contains 18 signatures and the petitioners request that the Minister of Health and Social Services grant funding for community wellness programs to the city of Yellowknife in 1996; however, place a condition on the funding that 50 per cent of the allocated funds be designated for youth programs.

Mr. Speaker, the third petition is from the citizens of the city of Yellowknife concerning the matter of funding for community wellness programs. The petitioners request that the Minister of Health and Social Services grant funding for community wellness programs to the city of Yellowknife in 1996; however, place a condition on the funding that 50 per cent of the allocated funds be designated for youth programs. Thank you, Mr. Speaker. Mr. Speaker, Petition 54-13(3) has been signed by 144 people.

Item 10: Petitions
Item 10: Petitions

Page 760

The Speaker Samuel Gargan

Thank you. Item 10, petitions. Mr. Erasmus.